The film Black
Mirror and the article “If You’re Not Paranoid You’re Crazy” shared the
common belief of the idea of privacy or more so the “idea” of private or secret
information. Both highlighted the willingness people have to have their privacy
violated if given the option to do so because one might believe that choice is
not a violation. Moreover, as with the example of having the tracking monitors
put into the car gave people a discount on car insurance, people believed that
they “have nothing to hide” but often do not take into consideration the smallest
private act such as picking in their noses while driving. People also tend to
believe that unless they are famous they have no reason to be “paranoid” or
under watchful eye. However, as mentioned in the article, people often do not
consider the other things that can be done with such a simple device. Just like
the computer I am typing on in the Buckman computer lab has a camera in it.
Before reading the article, I thought, “Oh, that’s cool CBU got an upgrade” not
thinking that the cameras could be used to monitor this computer lab, prevent
thefts but nonetheless secreting violating my privacy just like the “guy who
admitted to spying on his girlfriend through her camera”. Furthermore, we have
a tendency to trust that our government or people of authority would not
violate our privacy without telling us as it violates our right to privacy. As Americans, the word “right” holds an unforeseen
power to us. We think because it is our “right” the government will not dare to
violate such sacredness. Nonetheless, we see such violations when you get a new
phone number but receive calls from telemarketers or when we agree to have a
device placed on us to receive a discount. In such times, money is more sacred
than privacy or protecting someone’s privacy.
In
addition, Black Mirror illustrated
people’s willingness to air their “dirty laundry” just as people do on social
media. People will often post their most embarrassing moments for attention. As
sharing becomes the norm, people value privacy less just as the main character
was required to show his most private moments with a stranger at the airport security.
The movie and article make one wonder
what the future has in store for us. Will the government one day require us to
be injected with tracking devices? What happens to babies when they are taken
to the nursery after birth? Why would people want a device implanted that
records and broadcasts their memories? People value their special moments in
life and don’t want to forget them. In the case of Black Mirror, people illustrated a willingness to violate their
privacy if they felt that they were doing so for a good reason or personal
gain. However, the film also illustrated the idea of conformity and
consequences for not conforming. For instance, the young lady without a
recording device could not help Jason because she had no brain chip to dial the
police. They were not willing to offer assistance to her because she did not
fit into society. Lastly, at the end, we saw how conformity also is painful
when the main character could vividly see and remember every detail that was
not present.
Great post Tanquesha! I completely agree about airing one's dirty laundry. It is not a favorable thing that people just freely. That is not one of our societal norms but it is closely how people interact on facebook and twitter. I can see how if in the future with the grain introduced and a generation to grow with it, it would be apart of society to "share" so freely.
ReplyDeleteTanquesha Mills,
ReplyDeleteI hope this correspondence finds you well. I find most intriguing your point on how technology has slowly consumed our lives. You write about how we are in surveillance every moment of our day and how we have accepted or submitted to technology and though most do not assume that technology cannot be harmful, if under the wrong hands technology can be toxic. You wrote that at first your were "okay" with CBU having a camera in the computer lab; however, after some thought you considered the idea of us being constantly watched is sort of disturbing. I also share the same concerns because I feel as if technology needs to be controlled by the right person or else as you said you do not know when or who is watching the screen and for what purpose. Therefore, technology leads to paranoia.
Sincerely,
David