After watching the 1915 silent film, The
Birth of a Nation, I’m pretty sure I stared at my computer screen in
complete shock and horror for a couple of minutes. Actually, I was probably
doing that throughout the entire film. Seriously. It was that bad! And I don’t
mean bad as in “boring movie” sort of bad. I mean bad as in completely,
totally, and horrifically racist! I understand that it was produced in 1915,
but it shocked me that human beings could actually produce a film that
completely dehumanizes African Americans the way this film does, even back
then. In the scope of three hours, the movie promoted the Klu Klux Klan,
depicted African American men as uneducated, lazy, and violent, basically
designated African American involvement in politics as a terrible idea, and
contained so much more content completely inappropriate and terrible towards
African Americans. Not to mention, after researching a bit, I found that the
film was actually extremely popular back in the early twentieth century. I felt
sick. Though I guess I really shouldn’t have been surprised that our nation was
capable of producing and promoting something like that. It was definitely an
eye opener.
Ta-Nehisi Coates’s
article, “The Case for Reparations,” says that “between 1882 and 1968 more
black people were lynched in Mississippi that in any other state.” Coates also
discusses how the Jim Crow laws basically came about because of how many
African American people were denied a vote. The
Birth of a Nation displays the absolutely terrible and just plain stupid
thought process of white people in the 20th century when these awful
attacks on African Americans occurred and when laws against them were made. The
movie depicts African Americans in office and basically makes them look as if
they are not only incapable of behaving intelligently but also portrays them as
corrupt and twisted. I think the white people back then should have rethought
whom they’re calling “twisted.” Also, in the movie, lynching was depicted as a
“heroic act” to save the damsel in distress, who just so happened to be white.
Not only were African Americans depicted as incapable of politics but also as
monsters towards women. Yeah… it was literally horrific. One of my least favorite
scenes in the movie was when many African American people were elected to
office and depicted as drunk, lazy, and partaking in inappropriate business behavior,
such as putting their feet on the desk while working. Also, the movie depicts
Lynch, a biracial man, as being elected simply because African Americans
stuffed the ballot box. I think this movie displays how completely self
absorbed white people in the 20th century were to assume that
behavior of African Americans, when they were the ones who not only prevented
African Americans from voting but also began publically torturing them.
However, what’s sad is
that this thought process has not gone away. Watching The Birth of a Nation and reading Coates’s article allowed me to visualize
the terrible thought process of white people in the 20th century
while at the same time seeing how African Americans were actually affected. The Birth of a Nation depicts African
Americans as awful people and completely dehumanizes them. However, how is the treatment
of African Americans by police today any different than this? What about the
way the media constantly portrays African Americans involved in crime? What
about their unequal treatment in regards to politics? As Coates’s article
shows, the racist treatment of African Americans has not gone away over the
years; the ways in which racism occurs have just changed. While the actions in The Birth of a Nation seemed absolutely
shocking to me, what occurs on TV today is not really any different. African
Americans are still treated as criminals and are treated unequally. The
question is, how do we stop it? This same issue has occurred for years, and the
terrible stereotypes towards African Americans have not stopped. While there
may not be any set answer on how to stop racism, I do think it can be done. For
one thing, society can stop promoting awful stereotypes. The media can stop depicting
every crime committed by an African American and hiding crimes by white people.
Also, I think we all need to stop being silent! These issues need to be
addressed and fought. People like to avoid them, but avoidance isn’t the
answer. Racism is too important of an issue to avoid. While we may no longer
make movies supporting public lynching like The
Birth of a Nation, we can do more to ensure African Americans are treated
equally. It may be hard, but I do believe this terrible thought process that
has been handed down for years and years can be erased by refusing to sit back
and be silent!
In reference to your post, I absolutely agree. The discrimination that Coates mentioned in his writings shouldn't have been allowed. It's absolutely disgusting that no one stood up and said anything. Silence (could one argue white silence?) is what contributed to that, too. White people had the ability to tell other white people, "hey, this is wrong." Yet, did we? No, it took forever for people to finally catch on. Even know, it's so normalized (poverty and such), that no one bats an eye.
ReplyDeleteI think a potential solution could be using finally standing up. White people need to use their voice and tell others that it isn't cool. We need to help the ignorance in our own race in order to start breaking that bubble of silence that surrounds racism.
Some people say we should use our white privilege to do that, too, do you have any thoughts on that?
Following up on Destiny's question, it's interesting to see how certain people have actually used their white privilege to speak out against racism. However, I'm worried it won't cause a permanent solution. People will still only listen to white people's opinions rather than paying attention to those who have been actually affected by racism. Still, I think it's a start at least. There has to be some way to call to attention the ongoing problem of racism in this country.
ReplyDeleteWhite Americans back then seem like they did not care if they dehumanized other races because they viewed themselves above others. That movie was completely with the norm during that time and no one thought the wiser. The thought that a movie so insane and atrocious actually was popular and enjoyed is a blackspot on America. The problem today is that there are still people who think like that even though it is the 21st century. The only group that can fix this is us- Americans. This has to be a concerted effort by all of us to end the hate. People of all ages and races need to unify so we can correct this dark past America has.
ReplyDeleteEnjoyed your post Teresa. The points you make caused to me think of this quote by Dietrich Bonhoeffer (a German Lutheran pastor who spoke up against the Nazi's in WWII), "Silence in the face of evil is itself evil: God will not hold us guiltless. Not to speak is to speak. Not to act is to act.” So I agree with you completely that it is our duty (along with everyone else's) to speak the truth and speak out against injustice. We all have a common duty to help our fellow brothers and sisters out. However, we cannot help each other out without being vocal about injustices that are going on inside America. It is extremely sad that during the time of the movie 'The Birth of a Nation' that there were seemingly so few people that spoke out against the blatant racism that was running rampant through our nation. It just seems so crazy to me.
ReplyDelete