To
extend our discussion about artificial intelligence, it seems that not much
talk is to be had over whether one approves or disapproves of A.I. , considering
the fact that they are likely to emerge and to begin to blend into society as
has been shown in the various films we’ve watched. In the Most Human
Human, Brian Christian considers the many defintions of the meaning
of life from a human perspective. “Games have a goal; life doesn’t,” is one
point that is made clear when he explains what existentialists think. This is
interesting to ponder, in my opinion, especially because games and the quest to
be human came up quite often in the film, A.I.
Artificial Intelligence.
AI
Artificial Intelligence is about a robotic boy, named David, who is the
first programmed to love, and is adopted as a test case by a family who could
benefit since they do not have their son around. “Though he gradually becomes
their child, a series of unexpected circumstances make this life impossible for
David.” David goes on a long journey to figure out how he can become a real boy
in attempts to convince his adopted mom to love him so that he can live with
her again. He finds this courage from hearing his mom read the Pinocchio story.
He truly gained the desire to be loved seeing that he was capable of love.
David never willingly hurt another
human; the innocence he possessed drew up just as much care for him as I’d have
for a normal child. In a world in which robots were a normal part of society,
do we have moral responsibility to take care of robots (especially when they
are in the form of little children and with the capability to love)? To what extent do we love them back? In this case, the mom’s real son and husband
were not in agreement with keeping David around, so she had to sadly take him
away. Was she wrong to abandon one who identified as her son even though he
wasn’t a real boy? David wasn’t even stuck on this question, though. He was
motivated by love and fulfilling his dream of being happy and loved by his mom.
When he was in the home with the family, if David didn’t understand something,
he ask, is this a game? Usually it was. When he was being dropped off for good
in the woods, he asked if it was a game, and his mom replied, “no” with tears
in her eyes. As mentioned earlier, games have an end goal, unlike life, from
some perspectives. The end goal of human life, from an existentialist point of
view, is determined by humans. This is seemingly one of the distinctions
between humans and robots. Going with the idea that humans can determine their
end goal, it is obvious that robots cannot. There was a robot named Jo in this
film who was created to be a male escort. That was his purpose. The other
robots had specific purposes as well and when humans felt like it or were
displeased with the robots, referred to as mecha, they were destroyed. David,
however, is an exception to this distinction between humans and robots. Fueled
by love, David created an end goal for his own life, even though it is
artificial. The struggle to want to be
real and chase dreams is the human flaw that made David real, according to his
designer. Despite the fact that David was artificial, he grew to be more real
than any AI had been. If such advancement is possible…. if an AI can grow to be
just as human as a human and determine their own goal, then is their life a
game or is it real?
I love how you brought up how this movie makes you think more about our moral obligation to care for AI under certain circumstances: normality and innocent. You say that they portray him (and in the way he asks about it being a game) makes you believe that there might be some obligation. It is such a tough call. I also like how you inquire whether their purpose in life is like ours or game-like.
ReplyDeleteOh Rakesha, you watched my favorite movie, A.I.! Wasn't it such a touching movie! The gamer perspective is a nice way to look at life and the relation to meche. I would have to say it is a real one. Through time and principles of growth a being goes through experiences that help shape their perspective and path in life. Outside of the organic aspect, David grew in understanding of his situation and circumstances and did what he needed to do to achive his goal of finding his mother and having her love as well as being loved. Didn't you just love the teddy bear that was his partner!?! They were just so cute!
ReplyDeleteI think that it's very interesting that you mentioned that life doesn't have an end goal. I agree that generally life doesn't have an end goal. However, people do create or theorize goals for their own lives. Does that mean life is a game, a quest? Most would say yes. Life is a journey; we each go through life trying to find the right pieces to lead us to success. Despite what people say, we are not in complete control of our endings much like the robot in your movie because at any moment something can occur that completely wipes out all possibilities for that "end goal" to occur.
ReplyDelete