"Love
is a many splendored thing. Love lifts us up where we belong. All you need is
love!"
Moulin Rouge
is one of the most prominent romance films in the industry, just like
Casablanca. Both films are very similar, but I'll get to that.
First, to
discuss the film and the reading. In Diane Jeske's "Families, Friends, and
Special Obligations" she says that we are more likely to do things for
others that we choose on our own. We are more voluntary when it comes to favors
our friends ask of us than we are our own family. When it comes to our family,
it's more of an obligation than an actual favor, we feel as if we are supposed
to do it for them rather than doing it because we actually want to. However,
that's not saying we don't care for our family less than our friends, just that
we don't get to choose our family, but we get to choose our friends.
In respect
to the movie, Christian goes against his family and continues to write, even
though they tell him he's a fool for believing that anything will ever come of
it, but he leaves anyway. He comes to a place that's known for its wild and
exotic scene, the women are beautiful and willing, but there is one that is
very well known that they call the "Sparkling Diamond." She's
especially beautiful and the star of the Moulin Rouge, but she, as well as
Christian, has never known love. She has only ever known the men wishing to bed
her. Once Satine, aka the "Sparkling Diamond", and Christian meet
there is an incredible and strong connection between them. They fall in love.
However, there is an evil at play: The Duke. He has gained the deed to the
Moulin Rouge and wants Satine's hand as well, because this is the only way that
he will pay for it to become the most extravagant theater ever seen. So Satine
and Christian must hide their love. They are willing to go to the greatest lengths
just to hide their love. Which, in my opinion, relates closely to what Jeske is
saying. It feels more natural for Christian and Satine to be together and to do
whatever is necessary to keep it that way, no matter what the cost is to them.
Now,
relating all of this back to Casablanca
I can already see so many parallels. Ilsa and Rick fell in love in a time that
they both weren’t looking for it, but needed it. However, they weren’t meant to
be. Come to find out later, after the two fell apart many years earlier, Ilsa
was married. But that didn’t stop them from loving each other. They just weren’t
able to act on it like Christian and Satine. At the end of the movie, we see
how much Rick really cares for Ilsa when he sends her and her husband away to
America to avoid being captured by the Germans. I can safely say, in my opinion
at least, that love is a strange but very strong thing, and I think Jeske
captures that. We may love our families, but it will never be like the love we
have for someone else.
I like that you brought in Christian's family into your analysis. I didn't even think about that. According to Jeske, we have special obligations and so Christian also has an obligation to his family. But, he leaves them in pursuit of his dreams of becoming a writer. Perhaps this shows he has no real love for his family?
ReplyDeleteI like that you mentioned what Jeske says about us choosing our friends, but not our family. And in turn, this means we are more willing to help out our friends rather than our family, because it feels like we are doing a favor and not fulfilling an obligation. I find that to be really interesting, because reflecting on my own life I find what Jeske says to be mostly true.
ReplyDelete